nosirrah
  • Home
  • nosirrah Mnemonics
    • Africa by Numbers
    • African Central Countries
    • African Coastal Countries
    • Alpha Stars
    • Astronomy
    • Australian Governors General
    • Australian Inventions
    • Australian Nobel Prize Winners
    • Australians of the Year
    • Australians of the Year (Senior)
    • Australians of the Year (Young)
    • Australian Prime Ministers
    • Collectives by Animal
    • Collectives by Group
    • Colours
    • English Monarchs
    • Inventions
    • Military Ranks
    • NATO Radio Alphabet
    • Olympics (Para)
    • Olympics (Summer)
    • Olympics (Winter)
    • Order of Australia
    • Twelve Days of Christmas
    • UK Prime Ministers
  • nosirrah Songs 1 (A - K)
    • Alabama
    • Alec Guinness
    • Altzheimer's Garden
    • Anchorage Monopoly
    • Another Point of View
    • Beautiful Day
    • Before We Get the Rain
    • Blue Joey Kangaroo
    • Breakfast in Hospital
    • Byron Bay Song
    • Canberra 14 Sept 2015
    • Cats
    • Cellular Consciousness Movement
    • Closing the Circle
    • Cricket
    • Currawong
    • Death in the Family
    • Diddle-Diddle-Dee
    • Diggers
    • Don't Send in the Clones
    • Farewell to Graham Farrant
    • Farewell to Swinburne
    • First Ashes Test 2025/26
    • For Graham Farrant
    • Four and Twenty Blackbirds
    • Four Leaf Clover
    • Goin' Down
    • Golden Wedding Anniversary
    • Heart of Hearing
    • Help Line
    • If I Can't Take it with Me
    • If I was a Tree
    • In the Desert
    • Irish Stew
    • Just Because
    • Just One City (Melbourne)
    • Just One Village (Oh Bicheno)
    • Kepler's Laws
  • nosirrah Songs 2 (L - Z)
    • Ladies in Girdles
    • Lemon Tree
    • Lesson
    • Little Old Lady
    • Lonnie
    • Maria
    • Morning Roundup
    • My Didge
    • Pick-up Calypso
    • Open Your Heart
    • Oyster
    • Randy Newman
    • Rejoice with Me
    • Rising Damp
    • Scum
    • Self Advice
    • Shanty
    • Singer Healer
    • Slide to Depression
    • Song for My 42nd Birthday
    • Sun Woman
    • Tas Mania
    • That Woman Talking Blues
    • The Ballad of Isaac Newton
    • The Queue
    • There is Nothing Like a Queen
    • Thoughts on Recurrence of Cancer
    • Travelling the Road
    • Twenty Questions
    • Underpants
    • Waiting for a Ride
    • Waves
    • Wishes
    • When I saw HIm
    • Woman of the King Salmon
    • Wouldn't be Dead for Quids
    • Yellow Thunder Voice
    • You Have to Laugh
    • You Need Hands
  • Mnemonics Oscars
    • Most Oscars
    • Best Director
    • Best Female Lead
    • Best Male Lead
    • Best Picture
  • Mnemonics USA
    • Central States
    • East Coast States
    • Eastern States
    • Four-corner States
    • Great Lakes States
    • Gulf of Mexico States
    • Number of States by Initial Letter
    • Original States
    • Presidents
    • State Borders
    • Ten Largest States by Area
    • Ten Largest States by Population
    • Ten Smallest States by Area
    • Ten Smallest States by Population
    • Tornado Alley
    • West Coast States
    • Western States
  • nosirrah Songs (Spiritual Unity et al)
    • 8th Spiritual Unity Gathering
    • Ambrosia and Divine
    • Every Second
    • Evening Star
    • For the Children
    • Hole in the Ground
    • Monday's Song
    • On that Day
    • This Train (Unity)
  • nosirrah Songs (the IH years)
    • Brown
    • Collar and Tie
    • Cultural Gap?
    • Dear Kindly Samuel Dimmick
    • Dimmick House
    • Eternal Triangle
    • Introduction
    • The Dunny
    • The New Highway
    • The Uniform
    • The Valedictory Turn
    • The Warden Said
    • Victoria
  • Mnemonics Greek Myths
    • The Fates
    • The Furies
    • Genesis
    • Herakles
    • The Graces
    • The Horae
    • The Muses
    • The Phorcydes
  • Mnemonics Bible
    • Creation
    • The New Testament
    • The Old Testament
    • The Ten Commandments
    • The Twelve Disciples
  • Mnemonics Calendar
    • Chinese Calendar
    • Hindu Calendar
    • Islamic Calendar
    • Jewish Calendar
  • nosirrah Songs (Incest)
    • Buggery Blues
    • Dance Time
    • Don't Blame Me
    • Healing (Gestalt)
    • Jesus Where Were You
    • Oh Baby, Baby, Baby
    • Oh Daddy Dear
    • Waiting in the Kitchen
  • nosirrah Songs (Kids)
    • Fairy O'Mairey
    • Jack Black
    • The Dragon (Fire Down Below)
    • Wibbly-Wobbly Mountains
  • About
  • Mnemonics Natural World
    • Beaufort Scale
    • Clouds
    • Continents
    • Geological Time
    • Intern'l System of Units (SI) Prefixes
    • Mohs Scale of Hardness
    • Oceans
    • Taxonomy
    • The Elements (by Atomic Number)
    • The Elements (by Atomic Symbol)
    • Ten Highest Mountains
    • Ten Largest Deserts
    • Ten Largest Islands
    • Twelve Largest Lakes
    • Ten Largest Seas
  • nosirrah Cryptic Solver's Manual
    • Introduction
    • Starting Off
    • A Curate's Egg
    • What a Clanger!
    • What is a Cryptic Clue?
    • Rules for Cryptic Clues
    • Types of Cryptic Clues
    • Reading Cryptic Clues
    • Mental Considerations
    • Abbreviations
    • Punctuation
    • Foreign Languages
    • A Bad Cryptic Clue
    • Revision
    • An Example Solve
    • Vagaries of English
    • More Clues
    • More Clues Answers
  • Ladies in Girdles 2
A Bad Cryptic Clue
From the Sunday Times: ‘In first set, server’s ball simply flies! (6)’. Indicator: In Wordplay: first set server’s ball simply Definition: flies In the Wordplay the words ‘ball simply’ are totally superfluous and unfair. In no way do they contribute to solving, and they definitely can’t be passed off as a connector. The compiler might argue that the answer is included in the whole phrase given, but it is also included in ‘first set, server’s incredible action and power, as well as the hardness of the balls and the slipperiness of the grass court, ensures each ball’, and no compiler would argue for that. In any endeavour, the pursuit of excellence requires letting go of bright ideas which don’t work. Too often compliers are unwilling to abandon a ‘clever’ anagram or inclusion when it refuses to resolve itself into a good clue. Sometimes they can fudge around the problem by introducing a hyphenated construction. That was not possible here so the compiler deliberately broke the contract with the solver. Solvers deserve better than that. If you find a setter who often breaks the rules ditch him Btw, the answer is Tsetse.

We use cookies to enable essential functionality on our website and analyze website traffic. For more information, read our Cookies and Privacy Policy.

Your Cookie Settings

We use cookies to enable essential functionality on our website and analyze website traffic. For more information, read our Cookies and Privacy Policy.

Cookie Categories
Essential

These cookies are strictly necessary to provide you with services available through our websites.

Analytics

These cookies collect information that is used in aggregate and in an anonymized form to help us understand how our website is being used and how effectively our site is performing.